top of page
Search

The Sanctification of Disgust

Writer: timothyrgaines
timothyrgaines
4 days ago
9 min read

Updated: 3 days ago

The Challenge of Disgust


Out of all the things that motivate humans, disgust probably isn’t the most fun to consider, but it is very powerful, and for that reason, we should be aware of how it motivates us. Richard Beck’s work has illuminated how powerful of a motivator it is, and I’m especially interested in how it shapes a people who desire holiness. (You can listen to a conversation I had with Dr. Beck on this here.)


On the one hand, disgust has a role to play in keeping us healthy and well. We are, for example, disgusted by the idea of eating most things that make us sick. On the other hand, it can be such a powerful motivator that it may cause us to act in ways that override other commitments.


Psychologist Paul Rozin has identified three different kinds of disgust:


1)        Core disgust – This has to do with the idea of taking things into our core. Think of drinking spoiled milk or eating a piece of candy that has fallen on the ground and has picked up dirt. On its face, this is an obvious protector against disease. But consider one of my students’ examples when I asked her class what disgusted them. For her, it was chewed gum. She had no problem with chewing the occasional piece of gum, but the idea of taking a piece of gum out of her mouth and chewing it again triggered a disgust response. What made it ok in her mouth but disgusting only moments later, outside her mouth? Something leaving the body – the core – to come back in runs the risk of picking up foreign contaminants and introducing disease, and humans seem to be wired to avoid disease through disgust. What else can you think of that triggers core disgust?

2)        Sociomoral disgust – When a person is disgusted by something their society finds repellant, that likely falls into ‘sociomoral disgust.’ Often, sociomoral disgust is triggered by an act or a person which violates the social or moral expectations of a community. An obvious example in contemporary society is pedophilia. Though pedophilia was woven into ancient Roman culture, it triggers a very different reaction today; we are (I think rightfully) disgusted by it. Can you identify other things that trigger sociomoral disgust in your community?

3)        Animal Reminder disgust – The final disgust reaction has to do with those things that remind us of how close we are to animals. In essence, these are the things that humans do that animals also do. Usually, disgust triggers having to do with death and sex fall into this category. When someone confesses having a hard time with hospitals or nursing facilities, animal reminder is under the surface, because those places remind us of death and mortality. Sex also tends to arouse this kind of disgust in us; though sex is entirely natural, it is often considered ‘base’ and ‘animalistic’ and thus better not discussed in polite company. Have you noticed that sex and death, both natural to humans, tend to trigger disgust reactions?


All these disgust reactions, positively, keep us safe, healthy, and alive.



People who care about holiness tend to be especially motivated by disgust, largely because holiness is so often linked with maintaining purity. Consider ancient Israel’s laws, as seen in Leviticus. A people, identified by their call to be holy (Lev. 19:2), are commanded to avoid eating certain things (Lev. 11), regulate contact with bodily fluids (Lev. 15), avoid engaging in certain sexual practices (Lev 18), and having contact or proximity with dead bodies (Lev 21). Of course, one of the obvious benefits to these is a people who do not spread disease or introduce harmful elements to the community, especially in the ancient world without the benefit of modern hygiene.


Because holiness is so often linked with purity, contamination and defilement are negative motivators. It’s largely assumed that to lose one’s purity is to lose one’s holiness. Thus, holiness people tend to be motivated by disgust, perhaps even more than we are willing to admit. I will speak for myself: having grown up in a community devoted to the pursuit of holiness, I implicitly learned that it wasn’t enough to simply avoid those things which defile – good holiness people were disgusted by them. “Psychologically,” Richard Beck astutely states, “we feel that purity and holiness is achieved by removing ourselves from the gutter and waste” (Beck, 2011, 152).


A desire for purity combined with a strong disgust reaction often results in an expulsive impulse. We withdraw from that which could contaminate. We spit out that which we find disgusting. We expel that which pollutes the body or violates its integrity. Again, these are impulses that can keep the body, whether biological or social, healthy. We see Paul, for example, advising the Corinthians to expel a person who continually engages in drunkenness and sexual immorality (read: living like a Roman in a Christian community) (1 Cor. 5).


The Challenge of Jesus


As he often does, however, Jesus challenges the impulse among holiness-minded people to allow our disgust reactions to rule our motivations. This is especially important when our disgust reactions mutate into contempt against a person who represents a contaminant.


In essence, Jesus defangs the threat of contamination. Holiness and purity, he shows, are not as dependent on expelling that which defiles, as much as living in life-giving, vital intimacy with God. Purity is not achieved negatively by expulsion, but positively, by filling. That is, purity is a purity of heart, a 'singleness of heart,' as Wesley put it, willing one thing: to love God and neighbor.


In the first two gospels to be written, Jesus tells his followers that it isn’t what goes into a person that defiles them (core disgust), but what comes out of their mouth, flowing from what is in their heart (Matt. 15:11, Mark 7:15-20).


Mark 5 is a series of stories about Jesus stepping into places and situations that would have evoked strong disgust reactions. First, Jesus led his disciples into the heart of all things disgusting. Upon crossing the Sea of Galilee to the territory of outsiders, Jesus and his disciples are greeted by a man who lived in close proximity to dead bodies and was actively bleeding from cutting himself. There were also pigs nearby. Everything about this man and this setting threatened the purity of the disciples, who would have known and lived by the Jewish purity codes. The scene would have activated disgust reactions even in those who weren’t Jews. Rather than withdrawing from the situation, Jesus engages with the man, bringing healing and peace to the man. Next, Jesus goes to a the aid of a young girl when he is intercepted by a woman who is actively bleeding. While Jesus is talking to her, his disciples receive word that the young girl has died, and yet, rather than preserving his ritual purity, Jesus draws near to the girl’s body, taking her by the hand, and returning her to life. Again, everything about these situations were unclean – threats to the purity of any Jewish man. The central question of Mark resonates over all of these encounters: Who is this man? Apparently, he is the one whose holiness is not threatened by contaminants.


Jesus also scandalizes those most concerned with purity based on his table company. “He eats with tax collectors and sinners,” we hear people say in the first two gospels, signaling his seeming willingness to allow a contaminant into the community (Matt. 9, Mark 2).


Luke expands on Jesus’s table practices, issuing a further challenge to our impulses. While there are several examples of this in Luke (you can read a more detailed scholarly article I’ve published on this topic here), a standout occurrence is found in Luke 7:36-50. There, Jesus welcomes a woman into a meal setting. Jesus’s host, Simon, identifies her as a sinful woman and measures Jesus’s prophetic status according to what he does to respond to an external contaminant.

The presence of this woman triggers all three of Rozin’s disgust reactions: 1) She shows up to a meal (core disgust), 2) she is identified as sinful (sociomoral disgust), 3) and she begins kissing Jesus’s feet and wiping them with her hair (animal reminder). And Jesus continues to welcome her, noting that her love and gratitude distinguish her from the host who saw her as a contaminant.


Jesus’s mealtime challenge to our disgust impulse reaches its zenith in the final meal he shares with his disciples before his arrest and crucifixion (Luke 22). There, he took bread and wine, identified them as his own body and blood, and shared them with the disciples, even the one who had agreed to betray him. At that meal, he: 1) asks them to eat and drink (core disgust), 2) with a betrayer at the table (sociomoral disgust), and the meal he identifies as his own body and blood, signaling his impending death (animal reminder disgust).


When I approach the Lord’s Supper, I’m still challenged by Jesus. Indeed, he is still sanctifying my sense of disgust. That isn’t to say that my disgust reaction disappears, but it isn’t oriented as it once was. By grace, I think I see my disgust reactions being redeemed away from contempt for other people. By grace, disgust can be aimed less at expelling those who I view as a contaminant to my holiness and the holiness of my community. By grace, I think I see that my hope of holiness isn’t in expelling and external contaminant, but in being so intimate with God that the other person isn’t necessarily a threat to my holiness. My holiness does not require me to expel them, but to love the Lord my God, with all my heart, mind, soul, and strength…and to love my neighbor as myself.


After the meal and his arrest, Jesus was crucified and the integrity of his body shattered. He was run through with nails and a spear, and bodily fluids drained from him. His dead body was removed from the cross by those who loved him, violating their own purity. In the crucifixion of Jesus, God is shockingly and scandalously ‘contaminated’ by death while flooding it with holiness; God enters into death and remains holy. We really won’t get the depth and power of the gospel without this: God entered into everything that triggers our disgust, and it wasn’t a violation of his holiness. Our hope of holiness lies there, not in maintaining a track record of having no contact with disgust-triggering contaminants, but in following the crucified and resurrected Lord peaceably into places where holiness is making all things new. Jesus sanctifies our disgust by giving it a rightful place, but not letting it become a barrier to our own holiness.


The Challenge of the World


For holiness-minded people, the world can often appear as a collection of external threats to our holiness. Our disgust reaction motivates us to be on guard against any contaminant, and we are often most motivated to expel the contaminants that trigger sociomoral and animal reminder disgust. Sometimes, our disgust can mutate into out and out contempt.


One of the troubling realities of giving in to such impulses, however, is that it not only sidesteps the theological challenge Jesus issues time and again, but also forgets our own history. Now I’m talking about my own people, the Church of the Nazarene. We were born, to use Beck’s descriptive phrase, in the gutter. Early founders J.P. Widney and Phineas Bresee were reacting against a vision of holiness that was maintained by avoiding contact with possible contamination. Their work with the outcasts and addicts was motivated precisely by a vision of holiness nurtured by Jesus’s challenge. Work with the proverbial ‘sinners and tax collectors’ was no threat to their holiness; their work was motivated by holiness, seen clearly in Jesus. “In the impulse to become holy, we move away from the more dirty aspects of the human predicament,” Beck cautions. “In light of the Incarnation, the divine moving into the grit of life, this holiness via a flight from the body seems to be pulling us in the wrong direction. The church is pulled away from life rather than toward a deeper participation” (Beck, 2011, 153).


The Church of the Nazarene wasn’t born in the spirit that Beck describes, but we have certainly struggled with it. Throughout our history, our concern for holiness has sometimes been manifest by the attempt to expel the outside contaminants and shield ourselves from intrusion, rather than move missionally thorough the world, motivated by hearts filled with love for God and neighbor.


If you are hearing me say that we throw ourselves open to anything and everything, I’m either not stating it clearly enough or you’re finding something here that I’m not saying. Bodies still need distinction to function. Holiness calls for intimate conformity to the resurrected Christ, and not simply…whatever seems neat. I am saying, however, that we holiness people should be aware when we are acting out of a desire for holiness and when we are reacting out of a disgust reaction. Because disgust is such a powerful psychological force, it can often motivate us, masquerading as holiness, even mutating into contempt. Disgust triggers a defensive impulse to expel and withdraw. I wonder how much of our expulsive reactions are being motivated by disgust, even if we’re not aware of it. The good news is that Jesus continues to meet us with grace that challenges and sanctifies our disgust reactions.


References:

Richard Beck, Unclean: Meditations on Purity, Hospitality, and Mortality (Cascade, 2011)

 

 
 
 

Comments


Contact
 

To contact me, please use the form here. Thanks!

  • LinkedIn
  • Twitter

Thanks for submitting!

©2023 by Timothy Gaines.

bottom of page